Reliable general plumbing service in Indianapolis, IN

Peakzi's data-driven rankings highlight Carter's My Plumber as a top 5 provider with 5 skilled pros and a 4.9-star rating, praised for quality and punctuality. Act fast to save $50 on plumbing services—find trusted plumbers in Indianapolis on Peakzi now!

What Indianapolis, IN homeowners are saying

Customer reviews and ratings for top contractors in your area

Cindy Retherford

Review for Carter's My Plumber

5.0

PlumbingInstallWater Heater

Carter put in my hot water heater and sump pump. I have a maintenance plan on my water heater. Carter is the best. I enjoy working with them. Thanks for your services.

Kelli Graham

Review for Carter's My Plumber

5.0

PlumbingReplaceGarbage Disposal

This post is from Lea Shelton. They were prompt and provided quotes before proceeding with the work. Did a great job on garbage disposal replacing the flange and reconnecting for us.

Shawn IsHere

Review for Carter's My Plumber

5.0

PlumbingInstallGarbage Disposal

Had a new garbage disposal installed by Jarred from Carter’s My Plumber. Excellent job Jarred…it’s working perfectly. 👍

LaCarla Fetzer

Review for Carter's My Plumber

5.0

PlumbingReplaceWater Heater

Quick response and completion of service. Took special care not to damage home as the hot water heater was upstairs. Friendly service with a smile. Not cheap ($2k+) to replace a 50 gal hot water heater but it does come with annual services. (they did take old equipment away)

Marsha Davis

Review for Carter's My Plumber

5.0

PlumbingInspectWater Heater

Conducted annual water heater as part of original contract.

tool1573

Review for Carter's My Plumber

5.0

PlumbingMaintainWater Heater

Flushed hot water heater... very professional, thorough and responsive to questions.

Amanda Teltow

Review for Carter's My Plumber

5.0

PlumbingReplaceGarbage Disposal

They are quick to respond to my initial service request. I had a garbage disposal replaced. He was quick but thorough. Very happy with the service!

Jim Pierce

Review for Carter's My Plumber

5.0

PlumbingRelocateSewer Line

Tech was very nice and curious, came to relocate sewer line and placed pins for upcoming repair.

Thomas Adams

Review for Carter's My Plumber

5.0

HVACInspectHeat Pump

Explained details of my heat pump water heater, and offered solutions to get the most out on my water heater.

Russell Byrd

Review for Carter's My Plumber

5.0

PlumbingRepairSump Pump

Carter's continues to outperform the field. Great response time to am alarm issue on sump pump.

Daniel Paul

Review for Carter's My Plumber

5.0

PlumbingReplaceSump Pump

Sump pump replacement. Good explanation of options, timely completion of work. Competitive pricing. Very satisfied.

Janis Wright

Review for Carter's My Plumber

5.0

PlumbingRepairSewer Line

I was very pleased with the service! The conditions working on my property are difficult due to overgrown landscape. But they were very gracious about that. They arrived when they said they would and completed the work promptly. They originally thought I might need a new sewer line, which would have been extremely expensive. But when they investigated further, they found that the problem could be fixed for much cheaper. I appreciated their honesty and integrity. A less reputable company could have taken advantage of my ignorance. I was very grateful for their attention to detail and wouldn't hesitate to call them for future repairs.

Ali Anderson

Review for Carter's My Plumber

5.0

PlumbingRepairSump Pump

Repaired sump pump problem. Jarred was exceptional, went above and beyond to explain and help. Thank you!

Stephen Smith

Review for Carter's My Plumber

5.0

PlumbingRepairSump Pump

Luke pleasant & efficient and solved our WIFI sump pump issues.

Clifford Henry

Review for Carter's My Plumber

5.0

PlumbingRepairWater Softener

In the pass Carter My Plumber has always been great to assist with our Plumbing issues. I talked to Jodi on Monday & this morning (Wednesday) about a leak with my shower. He explained what the process of repairing the issue would be & discuss with me about having a water softener installed as well. I had Concerns which he was helpful with answering all my questions. Jodi Guided me through the financial process as well which I am very grateful & thankful for. Wesley the Technician was sent to my home to make the repairs & install the water softener. He explained all the details of what the process would be, how to operate the water softener, how long it would take him & answered all my questions Promptly. Wes did a great job on the shower leak repair & installing the water softener . I Especially appreciate Wes being patient with my 6-year-old grandson who was very observant of his work today. Carter My Plumber is a great team to work with. Thank You for your help.

DONNA M Ransom

Review for Carter's My Plumber

5.0

PlumbingMaintainWater Heater

Tankless hot water heater service, was scheduled promptly, appointment was on time, Peyton was professional, polite, & thorough!

brandon brimberry

Review for Carter's My Plumber

5.0

PlumbingMaintainWater Heater

Yes they will flush your hot water heater for 49$

Karen Crowe

Review for Carter's My Plumber

5.0

PlumbingInstallWater Softener

We had an excellent experience! Quick installation of a water softener and two toilet repairs. Very friendly and professional guys, made the process convenient from start to finish, and we have an great end result! Highly recommend!

Gregory Johnson

Review for Carter's My Plumber

5.0

PlumbingInstallWater Heater

Friendly consultant showed up on time and presented estimate for work. He was able to arrange for an install tech to come out an hour or so later. The installer was cleanly dressed, professional and we were back with hot water from a quality water heater within an hour and a half or so. Very pleased with the nicely installed up to code water heater system. Thank you Carter Team ( Trent, Joey and Brandon)!! Very pleased!

WILLIAM RINGWALT

Review for Carter's My Plumber

5.0

PlumbingInspectWater Heater

Water heater warranty flush

Alan Schmidt

Review for Carter's My Plumber

5.0

PlumbingInstallGarbage Disposal

Garbage disposal is quiet and no leaks. Work done well.

Kevin Kehlbeck

Review for Carter's My Plumber

5.0

PlumbingReplaceSump Pump

Replaced sump pump….excellent job.

Christine Spurgeon

Review for Carter's My Plumber

5.0

PlumbingRepairGarbage Disposal

They were available to fix a leaking garbage disposal within 24 hours. The staff is always professional and efficient! Great job as always Carter Plumbing!

Reba Pendleton

Review for Carter's My Plumber

5.0

PlumbingRepairSewer Line

I used this business for the hydro jetting of my main line because of roots. Jacob came out and did a wonderful job clearing my line. I was told by other companies just need to get my sewer line pulled up and fixed, one of them didn't even look in my line just quoted me something INSANE and basically said to have someone else do it, so I did. There wasn't trying to sell me other high price services I just couldn't afford at the time. I'd most definitely recommend this company for your ALL plumbing needs and when I'm ready for the big purchase of digging up those pipes I know who exactly to call. Thank you guys you've saved me alot!

Barbara Boemker

Review for Carter's My Plumber

5.0

PlumbingReplaceWater Heater

Highly recommend this company! I was staying at my daughter’s house while she was out of town and their hot water heater went out. Everyone at Carter’s was so responsive and understanding of the situation. They were able to replace the hot water heater the same day and the plumber that installed it was professional and friendly.

Neil Smith

Review for Carter's My Plumber

5.0

PlumbingInstallWater Heater

Wes and Jackson came out and took care of removing my old water heater and installing my water heater same day as the inspection. Very informative and willing to share information with me.

James Challman

Review for Carter's My Plumber

5.0

PlumbingRepairSewer Line

Just had Carter's out to fix a clogged sewer line. What a great company! I called at 7:00pm and he was done before 9:00pm. Thanks to Joedy for the great service. If I need anything in the future I will call Carter's first. 1/18/16

don paul

Review for Johnson Heating | Cooling | Plumbing

5.0

HVACInspectSump Pump

The gentlemen that did a wonderful job preforming my annual inspection. I asked about my old broken batter operated backup for my sump pump. They told me several possibilities to help me work around my system and also about their backup system. They saved me hundreds of dollars and I got a top of the line sump pump backup system. Kudos to Dustin Shotts and the entire team.

Zanzibar Ventures

Review for Johnson Heating | Cooling | Plumbing

5.0

PlumbingRepairLeak Detection

Mike Dzuba from Indiana Leak Detection was fantastic! Mike pinpointed the exact source of the smell in our home after others couldnt. Thanks to him, the issue is finally resolved! Johnson Comfort followed up with a prompt and cost-effective repair. Highly recommend both teams!

Ashley Manis

Review for Johnson Heating | Cooling | Plumbing

5.0

PlumbingInstallWater Heater

Our technician Jesse, was very professional and quick with installing the new water heater. Came and checked the problem and promptly replaced our water heater. From less than 8 hours from my call of needing it repaired. Can't say enough how great they were throughout this process. Highly recommend

mark b

Review for Johnson Heating | Cooling | Plumbing

5.0

HVACServiceHeating Services

Heating unit and tankless water heater service. Both techs did an excellent job. Will use again.

Joyce Cord

Review for Johnson Heating | Cooling | Plumbing

5.0

PlumbingInstallGarbage Disposal

Jade Miller was prompt,l; identified the problem and installed the new garbage disposal that we had purchased. He did an excellent job. Thank you Jade.

Kyle White

Review for Johnson Heating | Cooling | Plumbing

5.0

PlumbingDiagnoseSewer Line

I’m not one to write a review but I felt inclined to after my experience with this company. Rick, Brett, Sarah, and all the other guys who helped fix my main sewer line backup issue were excellent. Very knowledgeable, helpful, courteous, thorough, and professional. They diagnosed and corrected the problem and were not trying to nickel and dime me along the way. I know who I’ll be calling for any future home service needs, thank you Johnson Heating Cooling Plumbing!

C Rider

Review for Johnson Heating | Cooling | Plumbing

5.0

PlumbingRepairSump Pump

Jade did an excellent job of solving my sump pump issue. He was very professional and helpful in assessing what needed to be done. I highly recommend.

Christine Burton

Review for Johnson Heating | Cooling | Plumbing

5.0

HVACInspectWater Heater

An emergency after-hours visit. Possible drain back up, ruled out furnace and possibly water heater issue. Bob was amazing!!!

marleyanddylan

Review for Johnson Heating | Cooling | Plumbing

5.0

PlumbingInspectLeak Detection

Levi was quick to respond to our need for leak detection in our home’s foundation. Very professional and friendly. We always trust Johnson’s to provide good service.

Mark Scheaffer

Review for Johnson Heating | Cooling | Plumbing

5.0

PlumbingRepairWater Heater

Thank you for filtering the tankless water heater. Obviously you were correct about the source of the discolored water. It fixed the issue

Kelli D.

Review for Johnson Heating | Cooling | Plumbing

5.0

PlumbingReplaceSump Pump

Paul was fantastic. He replaced my sump pump quickly and efficiently. He answered all my questions and didn't make me feel dumb for asking them. He also brought an existing issue in my crawlspace to my attention and recommended a fix. I will definitely request him again. I have had issues with other plumbing companies in the past, but he absolutely put my mind at ease and he was very easy to deal with.

Lindsay Vandivier

Review for Johnson Heating | Cooling | Plumbing

5.0

PlumbingReplaceWater Heater

Evaluated leaking water heater and replaced with new water heater. Professional, timely service and easy to get on the schedule, even in a snow storm. The main technician Brett, answered all of my questions and was thorough in explaining the problem and what to expect with the new water heater. Even gave me some tips about my water softener . Would highly recommend Johnson!

William Hammond

Review for Johnson Heating | Cooling | Plumbing

5.0

PlumbingInspectWater Heater

Great service for plumbing inspection and water heater flushed. On April 14. 2020. had to have toilet, sub-floor repaired. Paul did a great repair. We are very happy and recommend Johson Plumbing. Replaced garbage disposal and did an excellent job-July 2, 2021. 10/05/2022. Bob Juergens was excellent in servicing our heat pump and getting ready for winter 🙌.

Aaron Hollowell

Review for Johnson Heating | Cooling | Plumbing

5.0

PlumbingInspectLeak Detection

I had a leak in my slab and water was leaking all around my house. I called Indiana Leak Detection and they came out and pinpointed the leak for me. Other companies said they would have to drill into my slab around my house to find it. Indiana Leak Detection was able to find the leak without any drilling. The whole situation was terrible, but ILD delivered a very professional experience and it was a great to have someone being so helpful. Thanks for the work!

Kim Zehr

Review for Johnson Heating | Cooling | Plumbing

5.0

PlumbingInstallWater Heater

Both Jesse and Nick went above and beyond to install a new hot water heater for our community clubhouse before Thanksgiving. Very friendly and great to work with!

Evelyn Crawford

Review for Johnson Heating | Cooling | Plumbing

5.0

PlumbingInstallWater Heater

We had an emergency with a leaking hot water heater. Jacob at Johnson got to us just past noon, drained the remaining water in the old tank and installed a new one, all within 2 hours. They are awesome!

Tim Crump

Review for Johnson Heating | Cooling | Plumbing

5.0

PlumbingReplaceSewer Line

Johnson heating cooling plumbing did an amazing job replacing the sewer line for one of my rental properties. They were very informative, prompt, and courteous. After the job was complete, the cleanup was immaculate. I couldn’t of asked for a better job done. I would recommend them to anyone

1 / 42

Top null Contractors in Indianapolis, IN

Highly rated professionals ready to help with your home services in your area

Recommended


Carter's My Plumber

Indianapolis, IN

Open Business Page

4.9 (2101 reviews)

Market Rank: Top 5

5 Top-Rated Technicians work with this company

Recently Verified Jobs: 1399

Known for Quality of Work, Punctuality and Brand Loyalty

Recommended


Johnson Heating | Cooling | Plumbing

Indianapolis, IN

Open Business Page

4.9 (1305 reviews)

Market Rank: Top 10

5 Top-Rated Technicians work with this company

Recently Verified Jobs: 142

Known for Brand Loyalty, Quality of Work and Professionalism

L.E. Isley & Sons, Inc.

Indianapolis, IN

Open Business Page

4.9 (1175 reviews)

Market Rank: Top 5

5 Top-Rated Technicians work with this company

Known for Value, Brand Loyalty and Customer Service

Roto-Rooter Plumbing & Water Cleanup

Indianapolis, IN

Open Business Page

4.8 (1339 reviews)

Market Rank: Top 10

5 Top-Rated Technicians work with this company

Known for Punctuality, Value and Customer Service

Mowery Heating, Cooling & Plumbing

Indianapolis, IN

Open Business Page

4.9 (1981 reviews)

Market Rank: Top 5

5 Top-Rated Technicians work with this company

Known for Quality of Work, Customer Service and Professionalism

Summers Plumbing Heating & Cooling

Indianapolis, IN

Open Business Page

4.9 (1366 reviews)

Market Rank: Top 5

5 Top-Rated Technicians work with this company

Known for Value, Punctuality and Customer Service

Broad Ripple Service Experts

Indianapolis, IN

Open Business Page

4.8 (1766 reviews)

Market Rank: Top 5

5 Top-Rated Technicians work with this company

Known for Customer Service, Professionalism and Brand Loyalty

© 2026 by Peakzi. All rights reserved.